Life While They Live It Part X- Theories and Wild Suppositions by. Paul Wartenberg COPYRIGHT: Once again, let me state for the record that I am poor. I am not making money off this. Mulder, Scully, and additional characters are owned by Chris Carter and Co., and I hope they know that it would be very nice if they didn't sue me for this. NOTE: I do strenuously apologize for not keeping up with this storyline. I had become overwhelmed with another long-term project, the Senseless 'Shipper Surveys, that took most of my off-work time. Of course, there's some time now before Season Eight begins where I can try to do a few more chapters of this story...hopefully. THANKS TO EVERYONE WHO WAITED FOR TWO AND A HALF YEARS FOR THIS. RATING: Romance, but nothing naughty. There is vulgarity (and in this story lots of it), but it's Scully saying most of it so we're cool about it, right?...oh, and hopefully a good-sized serving of humor (at least it was funny when I wrote it...) ;-) SUMMARY: Post-Gethsemane. What if Mulder DID commit suicide? What if Scully's cancer was incurable? I know, I know, that doesn't jibe with Redux, Redux II, most of season 5, the movie, and all of season 6...with the possible exception of Triangle...and also all of Season 7, with the certain exception of all things. Then what could possibly explain why Scully is back in high school?...and why Mulder is taking her to the prom?... That was the second year of the Third World War/ The one between Us and Them... There was all sorts of talk the first years after the Peace/ A million theories, a million wild suppositions/ A million hopeful explanations and plans... - "Nightmare for Future Reference," Stephen Vincent Benet April 12, 1982 Hoover Building 8:29 a.m. Section Chief Walter Skinner took a moment to glance up from the copy of the Post he held in his hand, noting that the elevator had stopped on his floor. Pushing past the other riders, he barely made it off before the doors closed to take the others to the higher floors. He didn't think as he usually did these mornings about what it would be like to work up there, in the assistant directors' offices. It was no secret, indeed it was part of his reputation, that he sought such a position in the near future. What surprised so many who knew about it was that instead of developing a habit of brown-nosing, Skinner had developed a habit of hard work and excellent field service. Most ladder- climbers tended to be arrogant and self-serving: Skinner was efficient and hard-working. This morning Skinner had his mind on other things. The Mulder case had been less than two weeks old and already he had run into enough hints, clues, and stonewalling to fill a whole year's caseload. It also brought up a lot of troubling issues, ones he couldn't necessarily share in either direction of the chain of command. The hiding and subsequent destruction of those X-Files had to have been an inside job. The files he had seen suggested a possible covert operation or more within the CIA or DOD, but now the FBI was somehow connected as well. That administrative hack, Blevins was his name, had received the assignment to investigate the files' destruction, but why it was assigned to a man with little investigative experience didn't make sense to Skinner at all. The assistant director responsible, O'Connor, had not answered his request to explain Blevins' appointment, and indeed he had no reason to give Skinner an answer. Skinner made his way past his secretary, who was busy on the phone confirming certain appointments, and opened the door to his office. He needed to check on the surveillance providing security to his teenaged charges in Maryland. With the files gone, Mulder and that girlfriend of his were... That was when he noticed the scent of smoke in the air. Annapolis, MD Scully residence Same time From the basement, Mulder heard the noise of a family waking up and rushing everywhere in utter chaos. It had actually begun two hours earlier, when Dana Scully stumbled down the stairs hurrying to get to school. She had dressed in Catholic school uniform like she was supposed to but was struggling to straighten the mess that was her hair. She made a lot of noise until Charlie angrily woke up to tell her that St. Baptista's was closed for Easter break the whole week. At that point everybody went back to sleep. Now, however, the family had to stir. Captain Scully had to head off to his administrative duties at the Naval Research Base just across the river from the Academy. Breakfast, even when it was just cereal, was still an important meal in this household. The door to the basement opened and Mulder listened to the feet stomping down the stairs. He was slightly surprised to see that it was Troy. "Didn't your family head back to Virginia?" Troy nodded, taking a seat at the base of the stairs. "Yeah, but I decided to stay for awhile, see if there was anything I can do." "Regarding the Diogenes Group." Mulder stated that rather than asked. He rolled up from the bed, placing his feet onto the carpet floor. "Pretty much. Your cousin Martin told me about you looking for your sister. About that would-be assassin who showed up in New..." Mulder shhed him. "Watch it. If her father found out there was trouble..." "Oh. Still, that's a lot of excitement for the holidays." Mulder nodded in agreement, glancing about the floor for a shirt that didn't look like it had been worn two days in a row. "I gotta ask you," Troy continued, "just...how did you get Dana involved in all of this?" "Huh?" "Where did you first meet her?" Troy sounded more accusatory than inquisitive. "Oh." Mulder flashed back to the excuse Melissa concocted. "I, uh, was at Oxford over in England at the time, when Dana sent letters asking about research on the Loch Ness Monster. The Exozoology professor had me help her on that." "And you decided to come back across the Pond to say hello." "Well, no, not just that. I was coming back this way to ask the FBI to renew their search for my sister Samantha, and I stopped by because, you know, it's on the way there and..." "Ah. Huh." Troy stated that, slowly. He wasn't buying a bit of it. Mulder stood there, a relatively fresh shirt in his hand, pausing. "What?" "I do have to wonder," Troy replied. "I mean, I just want to be sure...nobody in the Diogenes Group ever told you about Dana's family? Did anyone there point you in her direction?" "What? No..." "Was it Smith? Rumpole? Any of those cigar smokers from the Library?" Mulder scowled, taking a step toward Troy. "I said no." Troy paused. "I can't believe the odds involved in Dana somehow contacting you..." "Why can't you believe that?" Mulder took a moment to consider. "Is there something you're not telling me? What do you know about this?" Troy glanced away for a second. Should he tell him now? With what Mulder knows about Rennes Le Chateau... "I just think, the odds of you being in the Diogenes Group, looking for a missing sister, asking Dana for help rather than the Group members over here..." "Uh-uh. There's definitely something you're not telling me..." "Hey." Scully's voice traveled down the stairwell just as she stepped down into the basement. She lowered her head to glance at Mulder, her hair not as mussed as it might have been two hours ago. "You ready, Mulder?" "Hey. Morning." Mulder smiled slightly at his partner. "Uh. Ready for what?" Scully grinned ear to ear. "Prom dresses." Skinner's Office "How did you get in here?" Skinner tersely tossed his briefcase onto his chair, throwing the folded newspaper atop the desk. He turned to face the man still sitting in the corner chair calmly holding a lit cigarette between thumb and forefinger. The Smoking Man didn't answer immediately, instead taking a moment to enjoy his cigarette. He finally puffed out a cloud of smoke and answered, "That is of little concern. After all, nothing changes the fact that I am here." "That's not what I call an answer." Skinner stood next to his desk, scowling. "And besides, there's no smoking in this office." CancerMan smiled and stood, holding the cigarette close to his lips. "Do you know who I am?" Skinner took a moment. "I've got a pretty good idea." "You should know I'm taking a great risk in making such a public appearance this morning." Another puff of smoke. "I know you've recently been taking an interest in some...mis-filed documents within the bureau." Skinner's scowl lifted just slightly from the surprise. "You're the one who destroyed the X-Files." "They were of little value, actually. Just...pieces that would not fit into the puzzle needed to be solved. Loose ends, really." The Smoking Man tried smiling again. "Just think of all the cabinet space that was opened up." "The Mulder disappearance." Skinner clenched his jaw on this one. "You had a hand in that too, didn't you?" There was a long pause. "No." "Then why are your initials all over copies of reports ordering the search for Samantha Mulder to be ended?" CancerMan smiled through the smoke. "So. You do know who I am." "You haven't answered my question." Skinner thought about grabbing a folder or pen, something to hold in a hand before moving closer toward this intruder. He wanted some kind of weapon to point at him, just to feel comfortable about it. "If you're not going to answer it, then get the hell out of my office." The Smoking Man pressed the cigarette into an empty glass on the nearby coffee table. "No answer. A proposal, actually." Annapolis Convention Mall Mulder glanced over his shoulder. "Why did he have to tag along?" Scully, her arm wrapped around Mulder's, didn't look back, keeping her eyes forward. "It's okay. He's not bothering anyone." Troy was keeping three paces back on the couple, looking as nonchalant as possible but actually mulling over whether or not he should fill Mulder in on all the details of the Bloodline he was legally able to reveal as a member of the Viator family. He'd already revealed more than he should have the night before. It wasn't his place to even tell Martin, Mulder's cousin, about the secret being carried with the Viator family. Martin did insist, however, recognizing a fellow Diogenes member when he saw one. Still, given the coincidence that Dana and Fox... And just how did they meet? They act like they've known each other for years. And why is his cousin so eager to help Fox in his quest, someone she hardly knew? Melissa suddenly skipped up toward Troy. "Hey, cuz. You know, we left the watchdog at home." Troy grimaced, keeping his eye on the others. "Melissa, you have to know. You've been extremely protective of those two..." "Know what?" "Just how did Dana meet Fox?" "Oh. There was a research paper on the..." Troy glared at his older cousin, indicating quietly he knew that was just a cover story. Melissa stared back. "Is there something you know you're not telling me?" "The most I can tell you is that I know of Mulder's associations. He's part of a society of sorts. His interaction with your family is...an interesting complication." "I see." Melissa glanced away, back toward her little sister. "Are you part of that society, by any chance?" Troy took a moment. "Yes. That's all I can say to you about it." "Did you tell Dana?" "Yes. I actually told her a little more, but I swore her to secrecy about that." "Can you tell me?" "Not right now..." "Would you?" Troy stopped in his tracks and glanced down. "I'm not even sure if it was a good idea to tell Dana..." Melissa smiled at her cousin, albeit a little slyly. "Then why should I tell you anything?" Troy looked back up. "Whoops. Where'd they go?" Santino's Bridal Scully originally had no idea where to look for prom dresses. Her older sister wasn't interested in the prom her senior year, partially because of the family's move from San Diego to Annapolis and mostly because her protests that Stevie Nicks play went ignored by the organizers. Scully had to call Sylvia to see where she and Burwood had secured their outfits. "Oh," her friend noted over the phone. "You could always try the bridal shops." Scully, walking with Mulder through the mall, finally spotted this bridal store, fancy dresses lined up in the display window. She darted straight for the shop, dragging along a pale-looking Mulder whose reflexive male response to a bridal shop was hard to miss. "Yes!" Scully gleefully chirped, grabbing a long, blue-green outfit that screamed mucho dinero. "It's a good thing I've got Ahab's credit card..." "Um." Mulder had never gone shopping with Scully before. "Are you sure it's your color?" "Green? Well, I don't know." Smiling, she circled the round rack of long dresses, using one hand to shuttle past one outfit after the other. "I was hoping to save white for my wedding..." She watched Mulder get more uncomfortable before letting out a huge laugh. "Relax, Mulder." A petite brunette with glasses approached. "May I help you?" Scully nodded to her. "Yes. We're looking for prom clothes. Formal wear for him, a stunningly expensive dress for myself..." "You have your father's credit card, I take it..." "Um." Mulder stepped forward. "Can you make it separate bills? I will pay for my tux..." The saleswoman didn't skip a beat. "To your father's credit card too..." "Not really." "Ah." The woman nodded. "I'll go see if our tailor is ready to take your measurements for the tuxedo." Scully waited before the saleswoman walked away. "Mulder? How are you going to pay for it?" "Oh. Marty left some cash." "Ah. It's nice to know your cousin's looking out for you." Scully moved a little closer to him, holding a light blue dress with large frills along the shoulders. "But, um, about you and your father..." "I haven't spoken to him." Mulder ran a finger along one of the frills of that dress. "I don't think this dress is you, Scully. The frills look like they'll sit higher than your hair..." "I mean, I think your father tried calling a couple of times. At my house. Mom told me he didn't want to leave any messages or anything, and she thought I shouldn't tell you..." Mulder sighed. "They know about the argument we had..." "I think the whole neighborhood heard." He grimaced but stayed silent. Scully took that as a signal not to pursue this conversation any further. She placed the dress back on the rack and pulled out a dark purple strapless number. "How's this one?" "Makes you look like a Minnesota Viking." Scully turned at that voice. She glared hard at Marcus as he strolled into the store. FBI Headquarters Skinner found himself standing in the men's bathroom longer than he wanted to. After spending a few moments washing his hands, either for the anger or for the revulsion he felt, he simply remained glaring at his reflection. He shook his head, hitting the faucet handle once more. Cupping his hands to catch the quick burst of water, he leaned over and splashed the water into his face. Rubbing it on the skin. Rubbing his fingers at the corner of his eyes. When he leaned back up, he saw the black man standing there. He had the neatly trimmed beard and trenchcoat outfit of a professional. Only the small circular earring suggesting a pirate stood out. Mr. X, although not known by that name just yet, calmly stood there. "Section Chief Skinner. I think someone's already met you this morning." Skinner used the mirror to glance back, not turning around. Not just yet. "What would you know about that?" "That you might need to hear an alternate proposal." Santino's Bridal "So?" Marcus, Scully's ex-high school love-of-her-life, did his best to scowl at Mulder. "This is the pansy ass taking my place?" "Name's Mulder, actually." Mulder slipped quickly into his annoy-the-local-sheriff mode. "The pansy ass before me forgot to bring flowers." Scully lowered her head a little, glancing away to avoid eye contact with the two young men. "Guys, Marcus, this might not be the place..." "Oh, so you're Marcus." Mulder's voice went up just a notch, signaling an oncoming insulting remark. "You noted the dress had Vikings color. Football fan, I take it. Go Redskins." Marcus snarled. "Baltimore Colts forever, asshole." He got angrier the second both Scully and Mulder burst out laughing. Scully let her laugh peter out into a giggle, then a sigh. "Marcus, please, I don't think..." "I actually don't care what you think..." "Then why are you here?" Scully's smile faded as she crossed her arms. Marcus leaned in, giving Mulder a dark look before focusing on Scully. "You're a bitch, you know that?" Mulder started to lean in, but Scully brushed back against him with her shoulder. This was her fight. She knew Marcus was just here trying to start something with Mulder. Boys. "Yes, actually, I know that. Did you know you're a preening non-analytic debaser with an inferior priapic condition?" "Whoa." Mulder was impressed. Scully always knew how to form insults using words rarely seen outside of the Oxford English Dictionary. Marcus grimaced. "That doesn't even make sense!" A hand touched his shoulder. Marcus turned to face Troy, who leaned in and whispered what an inferior priapic condition meant. His family uses the same dictionary. The ex-boyfriend angrily turned red and pushed away from Troy, almost using a fist across the chin to do so. "Fuck off!" Troy smirked. "According to my cousin, you don't have the equipment for it." Marcus clenched both fists now and moved in. The saleswoman finally reappeared. "Can I help anyone? Before I call security to break this up and call your parents, that is..." The outnumbered teen snarled, glancing from Troy to the saleswoman to Mulder to Scully. Silently, he backed off and walked away. Troy smirked at his cousin. "I knew you two couldn't stay out of trouble..." "Excuse me," the saleswoman interrupted. "Despite the fact we would like your patronage of this store, for right now, I request that you all leave." The group glanced at each other and shrugged. Leaving the store, they watched Melissa stand in the main thoroughfare, tapping one foot lightly against the tile floor. "Babysitting never had to be this hard," she smirked. Washington D.C. K Street It was one of many limousines darting through the nation's capitol. The man sitting in the back seat by himself, enjoying a half-filled glass of whiskey and a half-finished cigarette, was a more unique sight. The Smoking Man knew that the proposal he offered Skinner might not work out. The man, even in this era, had his principals, after all. But principals can be manipulated just as easily as vices, and who knows? Even Skinner had a price, once before... The limo's brakes suddenly kicked, the jostling knocking the glass from his hand. Whiskey splashed across the floor of the limo and the lower part of CancerMan's legs. He sighed, glancing forward, noting the dark sedan parked at a intercept angle in front of the stopped limo. "Sir?" His chauffeur queried with a normal tone. It was broad daylight. "I think we will be taking one extra passenger with us briefly," the elder stated calmly, raising his hand to inhale just a little more tobacco smoke. The back passenger door opened, and without a word a trench- coated gentleman entered. The man known as Deep Throat took a seat opposite his colleague and closed the door. The Smoking Man nodded to his driver. "Give the other car a second, then continue to our destination." The dark sedan did indeed back up, giving the limo a chance to resume down the street. Traffic went back to normal as if nothing happened. The two passengers stared at one another, CancerMan with a calm gaze and Deep Throat troubled. "I know this isn't a social call," the Smoking Man smiled, "and I did just lose most of my whiskey just now..." "Dammit," Deep Throat growled. "A flippant attitude on your part will only get you killed quicker. The remaining members of our circle have called in Strughold. He is not going to take your purging of the First Elder and the others lightly and will more than likely have you offered up for dissection. A slow painful dissection!" "Don't you think I have anticipated Strughold's inevitable involvement?" CancerMan had finished his cigarette, and starting tapping another one out of a freshly opened pack of Morleys. "When that time comes, what I have to offer will more than likely ensure my survival." He lit his cigarette, taking a deep inhale and then blowing out a large cloud of smoke that circled about his head. "And most likely ensure your own survival as well. Why else have you aligned yourself with me?" Deep Throat took a moment to think, wondering how he let himself get so entangled in this one. "I only aligned myself because of the warning you brought of the future you knew, and because Bill's son was going to be threatened. But now...I am beginning to wonder if what you told me of the future really happened..." "Oh? You know me perfectly well. I'm not the liar of this conspiracy. I'm the killer." "We're both liars and killers, old friend." Deep Throat scowled. "And I don't think I know you that well any more. Whatever your future self was, it's a far cry from the person I knew just three weeks ago." He tapped on the window. "Tell your driver to let me out at the next intersection." They rode in silence for a few seconds before the limo pulled over. Deep Throat opened the door, then as he leaned out to exit the limo, he turned back. "Just what did happen in the future to you?" The Smoking Man smiled. "I died." Annapolis Convention Mall "You WHAT?!" Troy leaned his body so far over the table he practically laid atop it. Dana just kinda stared back at him, sitting calmly at the dining table in the middle of the food court. Troy had to restate it, trying his best to keep his voice low. "You DIED?!" "Well, yeah." Scully glanced away briefly to spy her sister and Fox waiting in line at the fish and chips restaurant. "Mulder and I died and we found ourselves reliving our younger years." Troy fell back into his chair, landing so hard on it he nearly pushed it off from underneath himself. He regained his balance and slid the chair back up close to the table. "So that's where you two knew each other." "Yes." "So it's no coincidence about him being in the...group and all..." She shook her head. "No, no coincidence. Although I'm wondering why you're making a big deal of that. Is there something going on that I should know about?" Troy sighed. "I've...already said more than I should have." "You've already told me about the Diagones..." "Shh!" Troy waved frantically at his cousin. "Not in public. Not here!" Dana arched an eyebrow at him. "Sheesh. Okay. Don't blow a synapse in your brain like that..." "It's just, well...my side of the family takes this sort of thing seriously." Troy glanced over his shoulder at Mulder and Melissa ordering the lunch. "Later. We'll talk about this later..." "What are they talking about?" Mulder whispered to Melissa as they waited for the Treacher's Fish and Chips to serve up their lunch order. "I think Troy's getting around to asking Dana about how you two really met," Missy replied, not looking back. "Hmm. Explains why Troy looks like his head's about to explode." "Troy seems to be keeping some news himself. He's not willing to share." Mulder shrugged, thinking for a second. "It's not too big a deal. Not for me, anyway. We'll just have to let you say the secret words..." Missy arched an eyebrow, much in the style of a Scully. "Oh? Celtic or Latin?" "English will do. But then you'll have to perform the secret handshake..." "This is getting complex..." The food came, and the two picked up the trays. Mulder added, "You'll have to solve a riddle given to you in iambic pentameter." "Do I have to sing the reply?" "Yes. And lastly, you'll need to secure the secret map to the ancient realms of mystic Mu." "Oh. I can just order that from Triple-A." "Just what are you asking my sister to do, Mulder?" Dana asked as he and Melissa arrived at the table. Mulder shrugged again. "Travel plans." Melissa sat down, sliding next to Troy as she passed the tray over to him. Looking up, she scowled and lowered her head. "Here we go again, guys," she whispered. Dana turned as Troy and Mulder stared in the direction Missy was spying. They spotted Marcus, standing along the far wall, scowling back at all four of them. The four regrouped around the table. "I say we ignore him," Dana stated. "I say we duck under the table, crawl out the other way, and go shop at a Deadhead store I know down on Hamilton," Melissa suggested. "There's nothing wrong with launching a thermonuclear warhead at the guy," Troy offered. Mulder indicated his own idea by simply standing back up and walking in the direction of the nearby restrooms. "Mulder!" Scully called out. She shook her head. "Dammit, this is going to get messy." Melissa placed a hand on Troy's shoulder as he stood to follow after him. She gave him a stern look. "Don't add to this, Troy. Let's just see if Fox and Marcus can just settle this on their own." Mulder waited for a few seconds in the men's bathroom, at which point Marcus burst into the white-tiled room. Mulder stood at the far end of the wash basins, nodding at the older gentleman finishing his duty at a urinal. The two young men waited until the elder man flushed, zipped, and walked out of the room. "So," Mulder pondered once they were left. "Are you certain beating the crap out of me is going to do you any favors?" Marcus scowled. "It's certainly going to make me feel a damn lot better." "Look. Scully broke up with you. Live with it. Get another girlfriend and enjoy life." Mulder took a moment, inwardly noting how odd it was for him to tell that to someone else after everyone else telling it to him. "I don't give a rat's ass right now." Marcus stepped up, fists at the ready. "Just shut up and bleed, you..." He got close enough to Mulder so that the future federal agent simply flashed his fist into the poor boy's face, just to the left of the nose. Marcus groaned, stepping back as both of his hands rose up to feel the pain. A small trace of blood appeared at the edge of the hand cupping the nose. Mulder just stood there, waiting to see what happened next. Marcus held his nose with one hand, glaring at his opponent. "Goddammit." Mulder turned, grabbing a few sheets of paper towels to hand to him. "Here. Are we done?" The teen glared back, but didn't reply. He placed one towel to the nasal bleeding and watched as Mulder walked out of the bathroom. Scully had followed the two as far as the hallway leading to the men's room. She watched Marcus enter, and then the elderly gentleman leave. She wanted to rush in, but decided against it, thinking it could make Marcus more confrontational. As she stood there, she heard footsteps down the hallway. She turned... ...and found the Choir Boy Jacob standing right next to her. Behind him, further back, were Daniel and Vince. Jacob quietly rose one hand at her, pointing a finger close to her eyes. She noted the tight bandages around the wrist where Mulder had used a crowbar that night a few weeks back. Scully stood her ground. "Yes?" "I just wanted to tell you," the Choir Boy hissed. "I'm not going to hurt you here. I'm not going to be so damned obvious about it. I just wanted to let you know, when it does happen, when I make you scream to bloody God, that you know who it was." Jacob turned around to walk away, but kept his head turned so he could glare at his nemesis. "After it happens, I'll deny it. I'm going to make damn sure I won't get nailed for it. But you'll know. Good-bye, bitch." She watched him walk away, followed by his two cohorts. She sighed, drooping her shoulders. Scully jumped as a hand tapped her shoulder. She turned to see Mulder standing there, a quizzical look across his face. She scowled, lightly punching him in the stomach. He nodded toward the departing Choir Boys. "What was that all about?" Scully sighed. "One more thing to be worried about." They walked down the hall, heading back to the food court and their not-so-warm lunches. "Huh," Mulder noted. "All this trouble for a prom dress." TO BE CONTINUED Part XI - 'Sincerity and Sufferings'